Federal judge overturns a controversial “joint employer” rule, making fast-food corporations liable for their franchisees’ labor violations by Sam Bloch

Last week, a federal judge in New York struck down a Trump administration rule that made it difficult for fast-food workers to hold restaurant chains and other corporations accountable for labor violations committed by their franchisees. Previously, a Subway worker who was owed back pay could only seek it from the owner of his particular restaurant—who may not be able to cough it up—and not the deep-pocketed corporation.

The overturned rule, which the Department of Labor finalized in January after years of legal battles, was challenged in February by attorneys general in 18 states, who argued that the DOL’s extremely limited definition of a “joint employer” would undermine critical protections for workers, and could lead to increased wage theft, lower earnings, and other labor violations. 

The judge’s decision, although expected to be appealed, could have profound implications for the country’s millions of fast-food workers. It could help workers recover wages, which the attorneys general allege are often lost in franchised workplaces. It could also allow labor unions to negotiate a massive contract for thousands of employees all at once, rather than organize workers store by store—a significant hurdle. If a company like McDonald’s, for instance, is considered responsible not just for the limited workers in its corporate-owned stores, but for the other 95 percent of Golden Arches workers employed by third-party franchisees, that would lower the bar to unionizing. 

Fast food and other chains have long claimed that a broader definition of a joint employer opens them up to specious lawsuits.

The judge’s decision is just the latest turn in a back-and-forth saga that dates back to the Obama administration. Fast food and other chains have long claimed that a broader definition of a joint employer opens them up to specious lawsuits. In 2019, the International Franchise Association, a trade group that has pushed lawmakers to settle the issue in Congress, said the broader, Obama-era definition of a joint employer cost franchisors an average of $142,000 annually in legal fees and other expenses. In a statement to The Counter, Matt Haller, IFA’s senior vice president of public affairs and government relations, said the group is “reviewing all possible options … to defend the franchise business model.”

At a time when independent restaurants are closing left and right, and chains are poised to thrive in their absence, the decision could put franchisors in a bind, says Mark Siebert, founder of the iFranchise Group, which consults for franchisors such as Buffalo Wild Wings and Auntie Anne’s Pretzels. 

“If the current rule stands, they can try to exercise more control, to make sure their franchisees are in compliance with all the HR laws that are out there, in which case they incur more expense,” Siebert says. “Or they can try to stay as far away as possible from control,” and risk losing control of the brand. (In other words, franchisees could start cutting corners on menu items, uniforms, decor, and other brand hallmarks—the things that make a chain store the same, no matter where you are.)

The narrower joint employer rule costs workers more than $1 billion in wage theft and other labor violations.

Labor advocates, however, see the ruling as a victory. For one, it opens the door to larger settlements from deep-pocketed corporations. Fast-food franchisees are smaller operations, with fewer resources; a worker may be unable to recover stolen wages, for instance, from a franchisee that declares bankruptcy. The narrower joint employer rule costs workers more than $1 billion in wage theft and other labor violations, according to a recent estimate

The ruling is also important symbolically, says Marcia Chatelain, a Georgetown University historian who authored Franchise, a book about Black McDonald’s franchisees. During the pandemic, she said, the franchising system has gotten more scrutiny, particularly when it comes to the issues of benefits. When McDonald’s, for instance, announced it would offer paid sick leave to employees, that only covered workers at company-owned stores—and not the workers at the vast majority of stores owned by franchisees.

“There might be a growing awareness of the various strategies that franchisors use to pass the buck on this issue,” Chatelain said. “There is a crisis in, if not wages, then in benefits related to restaurant workers, because of coronavirus.”

The Department of Justice is expected to appeal the case, but an appeals court is unlikely to rule before the presidential election, The New York Times reports

Add Listing
Most Recent Directory Listings
Total Passive, Tax Deduction up to 1 million, Diversify Financial Portfolio, Strong ROI
Maple Lake, MN
Critical need for clean drinking water. Your franchise and business opportunity resource from Franchise Biz Experts.
New GIG Carry Out & Delivery Pizza Concept
Mishawaka, IN
Be a part of a fast growing well established pizza concept based on the new GIG economy! Work smarter not harder!
Work From Home Franchisee Opportunity (A winning business model)
Allentown, NY
GOIGI gives you the opportunity to start your own IT company from your home with Zero Risk.
Pittsburgh, PA
Since we make donuts all day, people enjoy them all day! Groovy!!
Low Buy in /Low overhead
Forked River, NJ
Low Buy in. No real estate needed. We can get you started with any spending budget. We train you every step of the way.
Juicy Burgers Restaurant Franchise Opportunity
Las Vegas, NV
ll Juicy Burgers Restaurants® are exciting franchise business opportunities backed by a successful organization.
Team SEPI A Painting Company Franchise
Miami, FL
TEAM SEPI A Painting Company™ RESIDENTIAL and COMMERCIAL Painting FRANCHISE - Homes, Apartments, Condos, CAM, Commercial Centers and more
Field Service Franchise Management Software
Vancouver, WA
Waterstreet FMS is cloud based franchise management software designed specifically for Field Service franchise systems
AeroWest International - Commercial Odor Control & Scent Marketing Services Franchise
Baton Rouge, LA
AeroWest provides commercial deodorizing, scent marketing & fragrance customization services, with an emphasis on quality, innovation, & customer experience.
Area Developer -Master Franchise
Concord, NC
Executive Sales & Marketing
Network In Action Franchise Opportunity
Houston, TX
Franchise owners run 3 professionally lead networking groups that meet monthly.All Network In Action groups have only one mandatory monthly meeting.
Featured Listings
Edmond, OK
The egg-cellent way to start your day. With so many choices and so many paths to breakfast perfection, Jimmy’s is serving up breakfast, brunch or lunch with exactly what you are hungry for.
K&W Cafeterias files for bankruptcy The popular restaurant franchise filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy last week in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Middle District of North Carolina. RALEIGH, N.C. — Following the closure of two Triangle restaurants, Winston Salem-based K&W Cafeterias has filed for bankruptcy. The popular restaurant franchise filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy last week in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Middle District of North Carolina.
Franchises Want Additional Coronavirus Relief But White House Says No !. As Congress remains stonewalled on a coronavirus relief package, and President Trump politicizes the issue, many franchisors are worried that relief may come too late. For franchisors and franchisees, the merits of the various sides' arguments don't matter. All they can do is write letters and invest in ad campaigns, while their numbers dwindle -- as many franchisees close up shop for good.
Close to 20,000 Restaurants Have Permanently Closed Since COVID YELP'S LATEST REPORT SUGGESTS THE SECTOR HAS BEEN THE HARDEST HIT. Closures are on the rise for restaurants as COVID-19 crosses the half-year mark. Yelp released its latest Economic Impact Report on Wednesday, which, once again, placed restaurants atop its hardest hit sectors. Closures totaled 32,109 as of August 31, with 19,590 of those listed as permanent, or 61 percent.
'Stacy's Chicken Salad Chick' To Host First Anniversary Celebration In Rome, Aug. 24-29. Chicken Salad Chick Founder ... Brown embarked on her venture as a franchise owner in August 2019, ... numerous accolades including rankings in Franchise Times' Fast & Serious, ...Chicken Salad Chick, is coming back home to Rome, Georgia with a personalized version of her acclaimed southern inspired, fast-casual eatery.
Practical Strategies To Limit Premises Liability Claims . How to keep your business premises safe from Covid-19 liability claims. ... Practical Strategies To Limit Premises Liability Claims Involving Covid-19 ... Franchise businesses that open their doors to customers, guests, and other visitors ... A plaintiff who claims to contract Covid-19 on a franchised business's Franchise businesses that open their doors to customers, guests, and other visitors during the pandemic must be vigilant, not only to keep their premises safe to those who enter, but also to avoid lawsuits by individuals who claim they contracted Covid-19 on a business premise.
Bill Gates Sells Investment in Largest McDonald's Franchisee Barron's The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation Trust also exited the investment in the giant McDonald's franchisee. Bill Gates has exited his personal investment in the largest McDonald’s franchisee. His trust sold, as well. Cascade Investment.
Franchise Expo Paris: announces new dates for 2020 As the French government has allowed exhibition hall for shows and fairs to reopen in September, Franchise Expo Paris confirms its next edition from 4th to 7th October 2020 in pavilions 2 & 3 in Porte de Versailles. For its 39th edition, the most international franchise show will take place in a particular situation and sanitary environment.
Yum (YUM) Up 6.3% Since Last Earnings Report: Can It Continue? Nasdaq The downside can be attributed to decreased sales of franchise and property revenues, and franchise contributions for advertising and other services. Worldwide system sales — excluding foreign currency translation — declined 12% year over year, with KFC, Pizza Hut and Taco Bell falling 18%, 10% and 6%, respectivel
Jeremiah's Italian Ice continues franchise push with new units in Southeast. Jeremiah’s Italian Ice has exceeded in terms of growth. The Florida-founded franchise concept, who surpassed the 100 units awarded mark within the first year, is expecting an additional 224 units to be developed over the next five years through 8 new Area Representative partners across the country,
Curves Allegedly Lured Franchisees With Dodgy Sales Tactics. Law360 (August 21, 2020, 10:46 PM EDT) -- A group of franchisees hit Curves with a ... smell money" sales tactics to lure prospective franchisees into opening new locations ... "Most franchisees discovered that upon opening and operating their location, the numbers contained in the [disclosure document] and those figures ..
Captain D's Largest Franchisee Group Opens 40th Restaurant QSR magazine Captain D's announced the opening of its newest franchised location in Oak Grove, Kentucky. Located at 211 Claire Ave. off of Fort Campbell The Oak Grove Captain D’s offers dining room open at 50% occupancy, drive-thru, carry-out, and call ahead ordering with contactless curbside pick-up. Online ordering at, as well as third-party delivery through Door Dash and Uber Eats is also available.
NEARLY 200 FRANCHISE BRANDS CALL ON CONGRESS TO SUPPORT LIABILITY PROTECTIONS IN NEXT CORONAVIRUS RELIEF PACKAGE. Washington D.C. – Today, 187 franchise brands signed a letter requesting Congress to consider the passage of S. 4317, the Safe to Work Act. The request outlined in the letter includes ensuring small businesses that have implemented reasonable, good faith measures to mitigate spread of the virus in their communities are protected from liability claims.The 187 franchise brands in the letter represent hundreds of thousands of small businesses that employ millions of people in various industries throughout the country. These businesses urge Congress to implement protections that allow them to continue serving customers and keep employees on payroll.
“We Buy Ugly Homes” franchisee pleads guilty to attempted grand theft. VENTURA, California – A “We Buy Ugly Homes” franchise pleaded guilty to attempted grand theft. Ventura County District Attorney Gregory D. Totten announced Wednesday that Corey Evans of Santa Clarita pled guilty to two felony counts of attempted grand theft by false pretenses. An investigation was conducted by the District Attorney’s Real Estate Fraud Unit on a referral from Ventura County Adult Protective Services.
Black-owned franchise of wineries opens first Ky location Hilton Head Island Packet. That's what everyone kept telling Charlie Watkins when he began searching for places for the Franchisee location of Waters Edge Wineries.
LunchboxWax Breaks into Milwaukee: Signs Agreement for First Three Locations in the Region BOISE, Idaho - LunchboxWax, “an all-inclusive place for Every Body,” will open soon in Milwaukee. Walk into LunchboxWax with hair you don’t want, then leave feeling bare, beautiful and confident in just a matter of minutes! As a full-service speed-waxing salon, we deliver a unique customer experience. It’s true what they say about us —
ServiceMaster Global Holdings to Sell ServiceMaster Brands Franchise Business to Roark Capital for $1.553 Billion. ServiceMaster Brands includes a portfolio of residential and commercial services brands such as ServiceMaster Restore, ServiceMaster Clean, Merry Maids, AmeriSpec, and Furniture Medic, which operate through a network of franchised and company-owned businesses that generated $2,663 million in system-wide sales, and $256 million in revenue for the twelve-month period ended June 30, 2020.
How El Pollo Loco tripled digital sales in 2020 by modernizing its marketing. CEO Bernard Acoca explained how the restaurant brand revitalized its marketing after spending 98% of its media budget on TV and print just a few years ago. "The loyalty program is really the centerpiece of our digital flywheel and where we expect more and more of our sales comp in the month and years ahead."
'We Buy Ugly Houses' franchisee pleads guilty to felony counts involving Camarillo homes. The defendant in a real estate fraud case involving two elderly Camarillo homeowners has pleaded guilty to two felony counts of attempted grand theft by false pretenses, prosecutors reported. Cory Evans, 41, entered the plea Wednesday in Ventura County Superior Court.
Federal judge overturns a controversial “joint employer” rule, making fast-food corporations liable for their franchisees’ labor violations. For six years, the question of who a chain employee works for—the corporation, or a third-party franchisee—has been up in the air. The new ruling has major implications for millions of fast food workers.
Famous Toastery Accelerates Franchise Growth With Plans to Double in Size Over the Next Two years. After starting a franchise program in 2013, the North Carolina-based ... growing companies and Franchise Times' Top 200+ franchise opportunities. Famous Toastery has been one of the fastest growing better-breakfast chains in the U.S. As an early pioneer of the breakfast-and-lunch-only sector, Famous Toastery has made a name for itself by offering all-day breakfast.
Miami Attorneys Take on Major New York Franchisor to Land $1.6M Arbitration Award for Franchisees. A team of Carlton Fields litigators representing a South Florida franchisee that rose up against their New York franchisor with nepotism allegations have prevailed with a $700,000 arbitration award that, with attorney fees and costs factored in, totals almost $1.6 million.
Potbelly hires Adam Noyes to be COO Restaurant Business Online. Potbelly is in the midst of a turnaround after pandemic-induced problems brought it to the brink of bankruptcy earlier this summer. ... While at Checkers, Noyes led a franchise turnaround that resulted in more than 20% average sales ...Potbelly Sandwich Corp. has hired a longtime Checkers and Rally’s executive to fill the new role of chief operations officer. Adam Noyes assumed the role last Friday.
Former Black McDonald’s Franchisees File $1 Billion Lawsuit Plaintiffs claim they were set up to fail and not given the same chances as white peers.McDonald’s is being sued by 52 Black former franchisees who allege the fast-food giant pushed them toward poorer neighborhoods and didn’t provide the same opportunities as their white counterparts. The lawsuit is seeking roughly $1 billion, or damages averaging $4 million to $5 million per store. The group of franchisees operated more than 200 stores between 1988 and 2018 and claim McDonald’s steered them toward “economically depressed” stores that had higher costs and lower sales
S Leading chicken wing brand Spice Wing is pleased to announce new franchise opportunities for its upcoming ...Despite the current troubling times, the company has continued to grow and is offering an attractive low operating cost concept that is looking to close out on 10 new locations by the end of 2020. Spice Wing has assured franchise outlets in prime locations with low labor and low operating cost, backed by 30 years of combined restaurant experience
Cheesy Street Grill satisfies comfort-food cravings. THE LOCALE The third Cheesy Street Grill location (and its first franchise) opened in Wellesley in mid-September in the new sports complex on Route 9 east near the Natick line.
Cloud Kitchen Platform Kitopi Plans US Expansion After Raising $60M Yahoo Finance ... Kitopi plans on expanding across the U.S. after closing a Series B round of funding totaling $60 million, Nation's Restaurant News reported. Kitopi ...
Uncle Fluffy brings the delicious flavours of Japanese cheesecake franchise to North America North Shore News The fast-growing bakery brand plans to open more than 135 franchised shops this year alone, including opportunities for franchisees to bring the ...
Uptown Network Certifies Accessibility of Its Bring-Your-Own-Menu Concept. Naples, FL ( Uptown Network, developer of the BYOM™ (Bring Your Own Menu) technology, today announced that BYOM has been accessibility-certified. Achieved in cooperation with web accessibility solution accessiBe, BYOM lets restaurants and hospitality providers serve guests with QR-code-driven mobile menus on their personal devices that are open and responsive to everyone. By comparison, the common ways of making menus mobile—particularly PDFs on smartphones—are not accessible.
Motto Mortgage marks 200-franchise milestone Mortgage Professional America. Motto Franchising has reached another major milestone with the sale of its 200th Motto Mortgage franchise.This accomplishment marked its best stretch of annual franchise sales ever, given that sales efforts were mostly virtual during the second quarter due ...
Restaurateurs announce class-action lawsuit to force the city to allow indoor dining. A group of 100 restaurant owners from Brooklyn and Staten Island have banded together to launch a class-action lawsuit against the city over its refusal to allow indoor dining, the New York Post reports.
TIPSY A Fun Restaurant with a Relaxed Vibe Specializing in Tex-Mex Favorites
Cheesy Street Grill Franchise
Cheesy Street Grill Franchise
Batteries and Bulbs F
Pain, Injury, & Brain Centers of America Franchise, a Non-Invasive Pain & Healing Option
Little Guys Movers
franchise your business, franchising programs, franchise sales, operations manuals, franchise advertising, fdd, franchise agreement, registration, franchise attorney,
Amici Italian
Bad Ass Coffee
Advertise Your Business on
Franchise Gator Advertising
Maid Green, Made Clean, Clean your Office, School, Home, Business, We come to you and make you clean